Get Premium

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC Prediction, H2H, Stats & Betting Tips

USA · US Open CupThu, 21 May 2026

Columbus Crew

DLLLW

Thu, 21 May 202600:30

1 : 0

Full time

New York City FC

DWWLW

Pre-match win probability

44.3%Columbus Crew26.1%Draw29.6%New York City FC

Our prediction

Away · Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC listed tip from the board.

Odds3
Confidence44.3%
ResultGraded
Pre-match model probabilityPick and odds as published before kick-off
  • Columbus Crew 44.3%
  • Draw 26.1%
  • New York City FC 29.6%

Season statistics

US Open Cup · highlighted side is stronger

Columbus CrewNew York City FC

Recent form

Last matches · newest first

Columbus Crew0W 0D 0L in last 0
    New York City FC0W 0D 0L in last 0
      H2H
      Head to headNo previous meetings found between these sides.

      Betting markets

      Bookmaker prices with margin removed

      Goal lineOverUnder
      0.5 goals22.7% · 1.032.3% · 10
      1.5 goals19.5% · 1.25.4% · 4.33
      2.5 goals14% · 1.6710.9% · 2.15
      3.5 goals8.9% · 2.6216.2% · 1.44

      Both teams to score

      Yes57.6%
      No42.4%

      Double chance

      1X59%
      X241%

      Match result

      Columbus Crew2
      Draw3.4
      New York City FC3

      Both teams to score

      Yes57.6% · 1.62
      No42.4% · 2.2

      1X

      Chance59%
      Odds1.25

      X2

      Chance41%
      Odds1.8

      Columbus Crew

      Chance44.3%
      Odds2

      Draw

      Chance26.1%
      Odds3.4

      New York City FC

      Chance29.6%
      Odds3

      No half-time prices stored.

      No corner prices stored.

      Model comparison

      Our pick: Away at 3

      Columbus CrewNew York City FC
      Recent form50%50%
      Attack50%50%
      Defence50%50%
      Goals model50%50%
      Overall60%40%

      Columbus Crew vs New York City FC: prediction & preview

      USA · US Open Cup · Thu, 21 May 2026

      Columbus Crew meet New York City FC in the USA, US Open Cup on 21 May 2026 at 00:30 (Africa/Lagos). The recorded score is 1–0.

      On the 1X2 market the shortest price is Columbus Crew at 2. Once the bookmaker margin is removed, that outcome carries about 44.3% of the implied chance, with the other two outcomes sharing the rest. A short price means the market rates that side more likely. It is not a certainty, and the margin means the three raw probabilities add up to more than 100% before they are scaled.

      The 2.5-goal line is priced shorter on Over 2.5 (1.67, about 56.3% after the margin). Both teams to score is shorter on Yes at 1.62.

      Season points-per-game rates were not stored on this fixture yet. The odds chart still shows how the 1X2, goals, and both-teams markets are priced.

      Columbus Crew vs New York City FC FAQs

      4 questions

      What time is Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

      Kickoff is 00:30 on 21 May 2026, shown in Africa/Lagos.

      Which outcome is shortest on Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

      Columbus Crew is the shortest 1X2 price at 2. The margin-adjusted share is about 44.3%.

      What are the over and under 2.5 prices?

      Over 2.5 is 1.67 and under 2.5 is 2.15.

      Do both teams score on this match?

      Both teams to score is priced at 1.62. That is a market price, not a forecast that both sides will score.

      Columbus Crew vs New York City FC prediction, H2H and stats